Seafood Blog

Top 10 Must-Visit Seafood Restaurants in New York City for 2024

Top 10 Must-Visit Seafood Restaurants in New York City
Top 10 Must-Visit Seafood Restaurants in New York City

Top 10 Must-Visit Seafood Restaurants in New York City for 2024

When it comes to indulging in the finest seafood delights, New York City offers many options that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. From upscale eateries to casual seafood joints, NYC has it all. Join us as we explore the top seafood restaurants in the Big Apple that are a must-visit for any seafood enthusiast.

1Le Bernardin:

Renowned for its exquisite French seafood dishes, Le Bernardin is a Michelin-starred restaurant that has been wowing diners for decades. Chef Eric Ripert's masterful creations, such as the iconic "Almost Raw" tasting menu, showcase the freshest seafood ingredients sourced from around the world.

  1. The Mermaid Inn:

This charming seafood spot offers a relaxed and inviting atmosphere, perfect for a calm dining experience. The Mermaid Inn is famous for its oyster happy hours and delectable seafood dishes, including lobster rolls and fish tacos.

  1. Grand Central Oyster Bar:

Located in the iconic Grand Central Terminal, this historic seafood restaurant has been serving fresh seafood since 1913. Its classic New York ambiance and extensive selection of oysters, clams, and other seafood delights making it a favorite among locals and tourists.

  1. Estiatorio Milos:

Estiatorio Milos is the place to be if you're craving Mediterranean-inspired seafood dishes. Known for its elegant dining room and fresh seafood flown in daily from Greece, this restaurant offers a culinary experience like no other.

  1. Pearl Oyster Bar:

 Nestled in the heart of the West Village, Pearl Oyster Bar is a cozy seafood joint that serves up some of the best lobster rolls in the city. Their simple yet delicious seafood fare has earned them a loyal following among New Yorkers.

  1. Cull & Pistol:

Located in Chelsea Market, Cull & Pistol is a seafood lover's paradise. Its menu features a vast selection of fresh seafood dishes, including crab cakes, shrimp cocktails, and grilled fish, making it necessary for seafood enthusiasts.

  1. Fish Cheeks:

For those craving authentic Thai seafood dishes, Fish Cheeks is the place to go. With its vibrant flavors and fresh ingredients, this restaurant offers an exquisite culinary experience that will leave you wanting more.

  1. The Sea Fire Grill:

 The Sea Fire Grill is the perfect choice if you're looking for a fine dining experience. This upscale seafood restaurant offers a menu featuring an array of seafood dishes, including lobster, crab, and a variety of fish, all prepared with the utmost care and attention to detail.

  1. Lure Fishbar:

Located in SoHo, Lure Fishbar offers a unique dining experience with its nautical-themed decor and delicious seafood menu. Known for its sushi and raw bar offerings, as well as its creative seafood dishes, Lure Fishbar is a favorite among locals and tourists alike.

  1. Aquagrill:

In the heart of SoHo, Aquagrill is a seafood lover's paradise. With a menu presenting an extensive selection of oysters and other seafood delights such as lobster and scallops, Aquagrill offers a culinary experience that is sure to impress even the most discerning palate.

Additional Noteworthy Mentions

New York City offers an impressive selection of seafood restaurants that combine sumptuous cuisine with a romantic atmosphere. For those looking to share a special moment over a fresh catch, these venues set the mood:

The River Café:

Situated by the waterfront, this Brooklyn establishment boasts a selection of fine seafood and stunning views of the Manhattan skyline. It's a renowned spot for ambiance and gourmet dining.

One If By Land, Two If By Sea: Known as one of the most romantic restaurants in the city, this restaurant offers a seafood menu that complements its intimate atmosphere and beautiful setting in a historic carriage house.

Ocean Prime:

 A modern American restaurant that provides an upscale experience where guests can enjoy quality seafood and steaks in a sophisticated ambiance.


A more laid-back option, Seamore's offers sustainably sourced seafood in multiple locations. Its relaxed setting is perfect for an unpretentious yet intimate dining experience.

Key Takeaways

  • New York City offers extensive seafood dining experiences across diverse neighborhoods.
  • Restaurants combine traditional and innovative seafood dishes that reflect NYC's culinary creativity.
  • Seafood dining in NYC caters to various occasions, including casual outings and upscale, romantic evenings.

OceanBox Seafood is proud to offer a wide selection of fresh seafood options sourced from the finest suppliers. With our online website, you can enjoy restaurant-quality seafood in the comfort of your own home. Experience the taste of the sea with OceanBox Seafood today!

Frequently Asked Questions

New York City boasts a diverse array of seafood restaurants that cater to different tastes and occasions. This section addresses commonly asked questions, helping diners navigate the vibrant seafood dining scene in the Big Apple.

What are some other top-rated seafood restaurants in Manhattan?

Manhattan is home to acclaimed seafood spots like Eater NY recommends, which include high-end options where the quality of the catch is unparalleled. These restaurants are praised for their fresh, creative offerings and superb culinary execution.

What are the standout seafood eateries in Brooklyn?

Brooklyn's seafood scene is just as competitive, with restaurants like Littleneck in Gowanus creating a buzz with their fresh seafood and casual yet authentic atmosphere.

What types of seafood dishes are New York City seafood restaurants most famous for?

New York City's seafood restaurants are mainly known for their exquisite oyster selections, sumptuous lobster rolls, and the classic clam chowder. These iconic dishes are often prepared with a unique twist that reflects the city's cosmopolitan flavor.

Which NYC seafood restaurants are considered a must-visit for tourists?

Tourists seeking an authentic NYC seafood experience should consider visiting spots that offer exquisite seafood and embody the city's essence. Places with a mix of historical significance, iconic dishes, or picturesque settings are often at the top of the list.

Where can I buy restaurant quality fresh seafood? offers a wide selection of premium-quality, sustainably sourced seafood delivered right to your door. With OceanBox, you can enjoy the same quality and freshness that top NYC restaurants are known for, all from the comfort of your home.

Visit to explore our offerings and bring the taste of the sea to your table.

Shrimp, Crab Legs & Lobster Trio Box

Add to cart

Jumbo Canadian Lobster Tail Box

Add to cart

King Crab Legs (Wild Alaskan – 1 lbs)

Add to cart